The lack of toilets on Elizabeth line trains has been blamed for stranded passengers trying to force open doors and self-evacuate.
Damage to overhead power lines brought four Elizabeth line trains, two Heathrow Express trains and one Great Western Railway (GWR) service to a standstill for several hours near Paddington, west London, on December 7 last year.
A report by consultancy Steer for watchdog Transport Focus and regulator the Office of Rail and Road (ORR) found the absence of lavatories on Elizabeth line services was “a contributing factor to the passenger self-evacuation”.
Enjoy more Railways Illustrated Magazine reading every month.
Click here to subscribe & save.
GWR and Heathrow Express passengers initially had access to toilets and charging facilities on board, while the Elizabeth line passengers did not.
There are no toilets on the Elizabeth line’s £1 billion fleet of trains despite some timetabled journeys lasting 75 minutes.
The report stated that, despite frustrations, Heathrow Express and GWR passengers “remained friendly” and “stayed patient and calmly listened to announcements”.
It went on: “It was the opposite situation on the Elizabeth line, with no access to air conditioning, toilets, or charging facilities (and reduced lighting).
“Some stranded passengers started misbehaving and violently trying to force the doors open.
“One passenger noted that there were announcements saying: ‘Can people stop trying to open the emergency doors to get out… Can people stop kicking the doors – I know you’re frustrated but please stop doing that.’
“This further exacerbated the already stressful and unpleasant atmosphere on the train.”
Transport Focus and the ORR found that between October 30 last year and January 8 there were 75 incidents on Britain’s railways, leading to 178 trains becoming stranded.
These led to passengers being evacuated from 20 trains.
The bodies concluded that current guidance for stranded trains may not always be “well executed” or ensure an “acceptable passenger experience”.
ORR director of strategy, policy and reform Stephanie Tobyn said: “Being stranded on a train for a lengthy period of time is thankfully rare, but when it does happen, rail operators and Network Rail need to work together quickly to assess the situation from a passenger perspective and create a workable plan to safely manage the situation.
“This plan must assess the conditions on the train, the specific welfare needs of all passengers on board and the previous experience of public behaviour during such incidents.”
Transport Focus director Natasha Grice said: “Passengers can reasonably expect that the rail industry responds faster and more effectively to stranded trains situations.
“The railway’s responsibility to passengers doesn’t end when they eventually get off a stranded train.
“The industry must up its game to ensure passengers are properly looked after even once they are rescued, including onward travel and where needed hotels.”
Howard Smith, Director of the Elizabeth line for Transport for London, said: “We’re sorry that the incident on December 7 meant some of our customers were stranded on trains.
“We welcome this report from ORR and Transport Focus and together with partners, we have already implemented many of the recommendations and will continue to work to ensure customers have the best possible experience on our services.
“The Elizabeth line is a high-frequency metro-style service and as such, toilets are not provided on the train as adding toilets would be extremely complex, costly and would displace approximately 600 passengers per hour.”
